A supermarket owner in County Laois has said the Deposit Return Scheme should be renamed the ‘Deposit Return Scam’, after TDs called for unclaimed cash to be handed over to the State.
In 2025, consumers failed to redeem some €60 million from plastic bottles and containers. Now the Oireachtas Climate Change Committee has argued that the cash should be given over to the Exchequer.
On The Claire Byrne Show, Cleland’s Supermarket owner Alex Clelland said the suggestion is another example of why he dislikes the Deposit Return Scheme.
“They misspelt this when they spelt this scheme, they should have spelt it ‘scam’ because the only people that are profiteering out of this are the Government,” he argued.
Before the Deposit Return Scheme was introduced, only 49% of plastic bottles were recycled. However, that figure has since risen to 90%.
Despite this, Mr Clelland remains sceptical, although he conceded there are “some benefits” to it.
“We had to try and find ways of making this machine viable for us because it costs us money to have it there,” he said.
“It's still not viable for me at the moment; so, one thing that we did do is we spoke to local schools and asked them if they wanted to talk to their parents.
“So, they collect the bottles, bring the bottles and cans into the school, we put them through the machine and we give them the cash.
“Which is great for the school, [it] means they ask the parents for less money during the year for whether it be like outings for the kids or whatever it might be.”
A Re-turn Deposit Return Scheme machine is seen at a Tesco supermarket, 27-4-24. Image: Leah Farrell/© RollingNews.ieMr Clelland is especially concerned about the impact on elderly and rural people, who often dislike the scheme.
“They're not bringing them back and put them to stand in there, put them to the machine,” he said.
“They're just throwing them in their recycling, which they've done for years and years and years.
“So, from that point of view, they're out of pocket - but why should they be affected? Why should they be impacted by it?”
A Deposit Return Scheme machines. Picture by: Jonathan Sumpton / Alamy.Mr Clelland added that the cost of the Deposit Return Scheme leaves him “roughly” out of pocket €200 a month.
When asked if he believes some of the unclaimed cash should be handed over to retailers, he was sceptical.
“I'm not happy with it anyway, because the way I'm looking at it is, customers are paying too much,” he said.
“I mean, prices are going up because the cost of living is going up and the cost of living is going up because there's certain things that every retail business cannot control, whether it be payroll, whether it be electricity, cost of fuel, whatever it may be.”
Main image: A worker demonstrates a Deposit Return Scheme Reverse Vending Machine. Picture by: Stephanie Rohan/Newstalk