Allowing priests to marry would give them a “sense of reality” of reality, an Irish priest has said after Pope Leo reaffirmed the Vatican’s support for clerical celibacy.
When questioned on the matter by a journalist, Pope Leo said allowing priests to marry had the potential to “cause division” within the Catholic Church.
"It may be in the future that some things will change," he said.
"However, for right now, I believe an important part of my ministry of the church is to heal, bring people together."
On Moncrieff, Fr Paddy Byrne, Parish Priest in Abbeyleix in County Laois, said Pope Leo is someone who he “respects hugely”.
“I'm inspired by his example,” he said.
“When he heard the call of Christ for what to do with his life, he joined the Augustinians and their whole ethos and their charism is very much about unity.
“So, I'm not surprised that an Augustinian pope, the first Augustinian pope, a religious, would err on the side of not division or divisiveness, but rather try and coalesce the different voices that are well able to speak in relation to opinions on clerical celibacy.”
Pope Leo XIV leads the Sunday Mass for the Jubilee of Youth as young people and pilgrims. Picture by: Alamy.com. Fr Byrne noted that the Pope preached and ministered in Peru for many decades, a place where the Catholic Church is “very different” to that in Europe.
“The church blossoms where there's challenge, and primarily in South America and Africa and Asia, there's economic challenges,” he said.
“Yet the faith is very strong, it's rich and there's no shortage whatsoever of vocations, either to priesthood or religious life.”
Fr Byrne described clerical celibacy as “part of the baggage or the parcel of being a diocesan secular priest”, adding that the Church previously allowed priests to marry.
“I'm not sure whether it's a deeply profound theological question,” he said.
“But it's a real question for your listeners and people who come to church will visibly know that in Ireland, bar something dramatic is going to change, the face of the priest as we know it will be a distant memory in the not too distant future.
“Because the age profile, the average age of a priest in Ireland now is well over 70 years of age.”
A couple getting married. Picture by: Aleksei Gorodenkov / Alamy.However, he added that there is a "naivety" in thinking that ending celibacy would end the crisis in the priesthood.
“I think there's a crisis of faith,” he said.
“There's an instant culture, where we get excited about video games, staying up all night or whatever.
“There's so much distraction that the question of a personal commitment or a personal relationship with God, trying to spend time in growing in our own personal faith, the knowledge of the faith, all of that seems to be a fairly redundant practice when it comes to a very, very secular culture.
“Our culture doesn't do much waiting or even questioning.”
Overall, Fr Byrne feels that celibacy means that priests live lives that are “divorced” from a lot of the realities that most people live with.
“I think certainly being celibate, not engaging in the way most people do in an intimate relationship, having family, it certainly creates an ivory tower,” he said.
“I would imagine most priests know very little about lying awake at night worrying about a teenage son or daughter doing the Leaving Cert.
“I have no doubt that, if down the road, priests will be able to have family and have a partner or marriage, in my opinion, [it will] offer more empathy and a sense of reality to what we bring to our role in ministry.”
Main image: Pope Leo XIV. Picture by: Independent Photo Agency/Alamy Live News.