Manchester United ended their scoring drought, with Wayne Rooney getting the goal in their 1-0 win against CSKA Moscow, which takes them top of Group B.
The teams had been heading for 0-0 draw at Old Trafford before Rooney found the net with 11 minutes to go:
Rooney's header broke the deadlock for #MUFC tonight: https://t.co/3lNgM5hvfr #ChampionsLeague
— Newstalk Sport (@NewstalkSport) November 3, 2015
Meanwhile, Manchester City are through to the knockout phase of the Champions League.
They progress with two Group D games to spare after winning 3-1 in Spain against Sevilla.
Raheem Sterling and Fernandinho put City in control with two early goals.
Benoit Tremoulinas pulled one back for Sevilla but Wilfried Bony made sure of a win for Manuel Pellegrini's side.
Results
Real Madrid 1-0 Paris St Germain
Man United 1-0 CSKA Moscow
FC Astana 0 - 0 Atl Madrid
Sevilla 1-3 Man City
Shaktar Donetsk 4-0 Malmö FF
PSV Eindhoven 2-0 VfL Wolfsburg
Benfica 2-1 Galatasaray
B M'gladbach 1-1 Juventus