Coronavirus fine system will undermine community response to outbreak - ICCL


Michael Staines
Michael Staines

07.47 25 Nov 2020


Share this article


A civil rights group is warning that the new system of coronavirus fines will undermine the community response to the outbreak and make little difference to people’s behaviour.

The Government yesterday published details of a series of new fixed penalty notices for breaches of public health guidelines.

Anyone found to be organising an event indoors or outdoors, including house parties, now faces a €500 fine.

Meanwhile, anyone attending one of those parties or events faces a €150 fine.

There are also €80 fines for anyone found without a facemask on public transport or in shops.

Coronavirus fine system will undermine community response to outbreak - ICCL

00:00:00 / 00:00:00

   

On Newstalk Breakfast this morning, Liam Herrick, Executive Director of the Irish Council of Civil Liberties (ICCL) said there is “no real purpose” with changes to public health guidelines due next week.

“This whole approach really goes against the community policing approach we have had to enforcement of COVID since last April and would seem to open a lot of potential difficulties that really are unnecessary at this time,” he said.

Ineffective

He said the fines could only be justified if the Government could bring forward any evidence that they are likely to have any positive effect.

“What we know is that fines are a particularly ineffective tool to influence behaviour,” he said.

“People who have enough money don’t care and people who are resistant and don’t want to comply generally don’t pay fines anyway.

“That is our experience in other areas of law and it is particularly the case with regard to public health.

“We have international research that shows that fines are a particularly ineffective way to do this.”

“Particularly dangerous”

He said the fine system leaves no discretion for the Gardaí or the DPP – whereas up to now, “prosecutions could only go ahead as a last resort in consultation with the DPP.”

“This now allows these to be applied on the spot, which creates a difficulty that they could be applied unevenly in different sections of the population,” he said.

“All of the evidence at his stage shows that what is needed is clear simple messages to people.”

He noted that this is the first time it has been made a criminal offence to attend a house party – something that Gardai, the Government and the Department of Justice all agreed was “particularly dangerous” just a few months ago.

Coronavirus fine system will undermine community response to outbreak - ICCL

00:00:00 / 00:00:00

   


Share this article


Read more about

Community Coronavirus Covid-19 Fines Garda Government Health Minister

Most Popular

Live: Title

Now playing

00:00:00 / 00:00:00
Added to queue
Removed from queue

On Air

Share

Share


Up next

Episode title
Show
Duration

You currently have no podcasts in your queue.

Go to podcasts

On Air

The Home Show With Sinead Ryan

The Home Show With Sinead Ryan

09:00-10:00

Share

Up next

DOWN TO BUSINESS WITH BOBBY KE...

DOWN TO BUSINESS WITH BOBBY KERR

10:00-12:00

Share

FUTUREPROOF WITH JONATHAN MCCR...

FUTUREPROOF WITH JONATHAN MCCREA

12:00-13:00

Share

OFF THE BALL

OFF THE BALL

13:00-17:00

Share

TECH TALK WITH JESSICA KELLY

TECH TALK WITH JESSICA KELLY

17:00-18:00

Share

SCREENTIME WITH JOHN FARDY

SCREENTIME WITH JOHN FARDY

18:00-19:00

Share

TED RADIO HOUR

TED RADIO HOUR

19:00-20:00

Share

DOWN TO EARTH WITH CARA AUGUST...

DOWN TO EARTH WITH CARA AUGUSTENBORG

20:00-21:00

Share

DOCUMENTARY AND DRAMA ON NEWST...

DOCUMENTARY AND DRAMA ON NEWSTALK

21:00-22:00

Share

BEST OF THE PAT KENNY SHOW

BEST OF THE PAT KENNY SHOW

22:00-23:00

Share

THE HOME SHOW WITH SINEAD RYAN

THE HOME SHOW WITH SINEAD RYAN

23:00-00:00

Share

BEST OF NEWSTALK

BEST OF NEWSTALK

00:00-07:00

Share

DOCUMENTARY AND DRAMA ON NEWST...

DOCUMENTARY AND DRAMA ON NEWSTALK

07:00-08:00

Share

NEWSTALK BREAKFAST WITH SUSAN...

NEWSTALK BREAKFAST WITH SUSAN KEOGH

08:00-09:00

Share

00:00:00 / 00:00:00

Share on