Advertisement

Is this depiction of an Irish family ‘discriminatory’?

The Department of Education has come under pressure to drop a Junior Cycle textbook containing ‘a...

Share this article

11.33 3 Sep 2024


Is this depiction of an Irish family ‘discriminatory’?


Listen to this episode


Share this article

11.33 3 Sep 2024


The Department of Education has come under pressure to drop a Junior Cycle textbook containing ‘absurdly misconceived and discriminatory’ depictions of an Irish family.

The book, which is part of the SPHE curriculum, contrasts a ‘traditional Irish family’ with another from a mixed background.

The Irish family, depicted outside a thatched cottage and all wearing Aran jumpers, eat ‘potatoes, bacon and cabbage every day’, ‘do not like change or difference’ and the children ‘get told off if we mix with people with a different religion from ours as they would be a bad influence on us’.

In contrast, the mixed-race family ‘love change and difference’, eat ‘curry, pizza and Asian food’ and spend their time travelling internationally and visiting art galleries…

Is it really this bad? Or is it an overreaction?

Guest host Clare McKenna is joined by listeners to discuss.


Read more about

Lunchtime Live Highlights

Related Episodes

Movies and TV: Practical Magic...

00:12:18

Movies and TV: Practical Magic 2, The Paper, Mayday

The Hard Shoulder

00:12:18


The Last Days of Dalymount cel...

00:05:50

The Last Days of Dalymount celebrates music in the football ground

The Hard Shoulder

00:05:50


9/11 commemorations on the 25t...

00:10:44

9/11 commemorations on the 25th anniversary - Emily Keegan Reports

The Hard Shoulder

00:10:44


Are mid-rise apartments an ans...

00:05:38

Are mid-rise apartments an answer to our housing crisis?

The Hard Shoulder

00:05:38